Article on the
value of meditation in children
LA Times on 5th September 2005
TEN-YEAR-OLD Trae Smith knows how to deal with the stresses of
school, an acting and modeling career and, of course, the typical
family squabbles. He closes his eyes, counts to 100 and lets it
all go.
Trae, who learned to meditate last year with his fourth-grade class
at Toluca Lake Elementary School, said that tests and auditions
used to make him nervous. But since he's learned how to meditate,
Trae says, "everything is like a piece of cake."
As meditation goes mainstream among American adults, it's slowly
making its way into schools and programs for children across the
country. Anecdotal reports of its success have become common, with
parents and teachers contending that it can calm kids down, level
out their moods and help them focus. Some proponents say it can
even manage serious conditions, such as anxiety and attention deficit
disorder.
Now the practice is getting a closer look. Researchers are beginning
to study groups of meditating children to determine how the practice
might affect a developing brain. Although the findings have been
encouraging, some child-health experts are cautioning that, until
more is known, meditation shouldn't be touted as a cure-all for
stressed-out, hyperactive or underperforming kids.
Most of these in-school programs draw on parents' and teachers'
personal experience, rather than scientific research, points out
a new report from the Garrison Institute, a nonprofit think tank
that studies meditation and other contemplative practices. Dozens
of such programs exist in schools across the country, the report
said, with many more programs for children offered in after-school
clubs, religious and meditation centers, and through independent
organizations.
Research focuses on adults
A growing body of meditation research conducted in university and
hospital settings has supported a range of health benefits, including
reduced blood pressure and stress, improved immune function and
better mood. But the research, says the report, has focused almost
exclusively on adults.
Many meditation enthusiasts nevertheless have concluded the practice
could have similar effects in children.
"Not a day goes by that I don't get a request from somebody"
wanting to teach meditation to children or study its effects, said
Susan Kaiser Greenland, founder and executive director of the nonprofit
Inner Kids Foundation in Los Angeles. The organization, which teaches
mindfulness meditation in schools and supports research on the topic,
has cooperated with UCLA researchers studying the effects of meditation
on pain, mood and attention in children.
Two major types of meditation are being scrutinized for the benefits
they may offer in school settings: those that clear the mind, like
transcendental meditation, and those that increase awareness of
the moment, like so-called mindfulness meditation and other Buddhist-inspired
practices.
Both are designed to help kids slow down in a world of busy, activity-packed
days. And both must be altered for use in children. In many programs
for young meditators, silent, seated meditation is either brief
or nonexistent, and games and activities replace books or lectures
to teach mindful awareness, or mindfulness, which Greenland describes
as "noticing experiences without labeling them good or bad."
"This world we're in now, everything moves so fast,"
she said. "No one is taking the time to talk to these kids
about slowing down or about what they're missing."
Students like it, want it
Meditation lessons at Toluca Lake Elementary School consist of
breathing exercises and quiet nature walks. They began when teacher
Steve Reidman turned to Greenland, a friend, to help him manage
a particularly unruly class three years ago. "It was like night
and day by the end of the [first] year," said Reidman.
The meditation techniques helped his students calm down "well
before they got to the point of lashing out at each other,"
he said. Inspired by what he saw in Reidman's class, Toluca Lake
teacher Dan Murphy's second-grade class started meditating too.
Students who've learned to meditate in school say they've learned
to control their emotions before tests and big sporting events,
even during fights with parents and siblings, by simply pausing
and slowing their breathing. Fourth-grader Vanessa Macademia says
the technique relaxes and refreshes her, "especially when I'm
sad or really mad or just want to destroy some other person."
At the small, private Odyssey Middle School in San Mateo, each
day starts with physical activity followed by meditation building
up to a class trip to Japan in eighth grade, where the students
meditate alongside monks in a Buddhist temple. Head of school Steve
Smuin says he sees students reaching for the technique before exams.
"Rather than saying, 'Let's cram,' they say, 'Let's take time
to clear our minds,'" Smuin said.
As word spreads about how useful meditation can be, more students
want to learn the technique.
At Conte West Hills, a magnet school for inner-city kids in New
Haven, Conn., guidance counselor Linda Baker says attendance has
skyrocketed in her after-school relaxation program, which guides
kids through meditation, yoga and related activities.
"In the beginning we had five kids, now we have waiting lists,"
said Baker, who started the program five years ago.
In an attempt to quantify the effects of such techniques in children,
Randye Semple, now a research scientist at the New York State Psychiatric
Institute, taught breathing and mindfulness exercises to a group
of 25 9- to 12-year-olds with reading difficulties, including several
with anxiety and attention deficit disorders.
By learning to see the negative spaces formed by a cluster of blocks
or to describe how a piece of music made them feel, the students
became more adept at using all of their senses. As a result, they
began to explore new sights and sounds before labeling them good
or bad, fun or boring.
"We got amazing results," Semple said. Over the course
of 12 weeks, the mindfulness practices helped the children to stop
making snap judgments. They were also less anxious and depressed
and more able to focus results that ultimately helped improve
their reading skills too, Semple said.
Better moods, less anxiety
With research on meditation in children yielding largely positive
results, some schools are using meditation techniques to treat
or prevent common emotional and psychological disorders that
can be barriers to learning, such as anxiety and attention deficit
disorders.
Research on students at the Nataki Talibah Schoolhouse in Detroit,
where students and teachers do 10 minutes of transcendental meditation
at the start and end of each school day, showed that meditating
students had better moods and less anxiety than a group of non-meditating
students used for comparison. The study was published in Focus on
Complementary and Alternative Therapies in 2003.
A study of inner-city students with hypertension in Augusta, Ga.,
showed that transcendental meditation could have physiological benefits
too. In a report on the study published in the American Journal
of Hypertension last year, Dr. Vernon Barnes, professor of physiology
at the Medical College of Georgia, showed that students who stuck
to a program of 15 minutes of meditation twice a day lowered their
blood pressure by more than three millimeters on average and kept
it low for up to four months.
Preliminary evidence on meditation's ability to reduce anxiety
and its symptoms in children is promising, said Susan Smalley, a
professor of psychiatry and biobehavioral sciences at UCLA. This
fall, she'll begin a pilot study examining the effects of mindfulness
meditation on fifth-graders with attention deficit disorder.
She's particularly encouraged by findings that suggest mindfulness
practices can "rewire" the brain.
Studies in adults have shown that the brain's prefrontal cortex
(a region at the front of the brain) plays a big role in focusing
attention. People with attention disorders display less activity
in this region than people without the disorder.
Jeffrey Schwartz, a research psychiatrist at UCLA, said willfully
directing attention increased activity in the prefrontal cortex.
And mindfulness meditation, with its emphasis on paying attention,
appears to strengthen the prefrontal cortex, said Schwartz, whose
own research has examined how mindfulness techniques can be used
to overcome obsessive compulsive disorder.
"That's what's so exciting for so many people about doing
this [meditation] with kids," said Inner Kids' Greenland. "If
you can start early on to help them train their ability to pay attention,
the brain will become a stronger muscle."
But because the prefrontal cortex is one of the last regions of
the brain to develop (usually not until the 20s), some psychiatric
experts caution against applying such evidence to children.
Teaching children a technique their brains are not ready for could
potentially frustrate them, creating or aggravating anxiety instead
of allaying it, said Amishi Jha, an assistant professor of psychology
at the University of Pennsylvania who served as a scientific advisor
for the Garrison Institute report. Her own research focuses on the
brain patterns related to memory and attention.
Furthermore, said Jha, it's possible that meditation techniques
could help one type of attention at the expense of others. Meditation
strengthens selective or focused attention, which is crucial for,
say, reading a book. But improving only selective attention might
hurt the development of flexible or open attention, she said, which
people use to monitor their environment as a whole. Both types are
critical for learning. Children need selective attention to stay
focused, but if their flexible attention is weak, they'll have trouble
taking in more than one piece of information at a time.
Studying the effects
Researchers agree that we are at the very beginning of understanding
whether meditation can affect a child's brain and body and,
if so, then how.
Still, many parents and teachers are convinced of its benefits.
They say that with meditation, "some kids will suddenly go
from Ds to Bs and A's and that's great," said Dr. Donald
Greydanus, a professor of pediatrics and human development at Michigan
State University at Kalamazoo and the author of several books on
adolescent health and behavior.
"Folks like me are always eager to look at new data,"
Greydanus added, "but at this point the research just isn't
there."
Trae Smith is convinced of meditation's usefulness, however. Asked
whether he'll meditate now that he's in fifth grade where
the math is full of fractions and the language arts get tougher
he said: "I think I'll be doing it a lot this year."
|